Mohammed Siraj’s omission from India’s XI for the first Test against New Zealand in Wellington became the biggest talking point of the opening day — and the criticism only grew as the hosts recovered from 70 for 5 to 243 for 5 at stumps.
India picked four specialist fast bowlers for the Basin Reserve Test, led by Jasprit Bumrah with Prasidh Krishna, Akash Deep and Anshul Kamboj, plus Washington Sundar as the lone spinner; Ravindra Jadeja was also left out. But it was Siraj’s absence that stunned former players and fans: he has played every Test for India — 18 in a row — since the Mumbai Test against New Zealand in November 2024, and this was the first time since 2022 he had not been picked for an away Test.
Sunil Gavaskar led the reaction on Sony Sports within minutes of the toss. “I don’t think he has let India down. He has never let India down. Why he has not been picked is something I don’t know. I only hope the others who have been picked ahead of him deliver,” Gavaskar said. At tea he added it was hard to accept Siraj was not among India’s four best quicks.
Harsha Bhogle was blunter still. “Flabbergasted and disappointed that India have left out Siraj. He has done everything asked of him, lifted the attack in the absence of Bumrah, been a great, positive team player. You have to wish Kamboj well but I hope there are some very honest conversations with Siraj taking place,” he posted. Ravichandran Ashwin called it “Harsh, very Harsh but this is the new normal,” while Ravi Shastri asked: “Where was MOHD SIRAJ? Experience, aggression and the ability to make things happen with the ball.”
The case for Siraj writes itself. He took 23 wickets on the five-Test tour of England and has repeatedly lifted the attack in Bumrah’s absence. Day one in Wellington only sharpened the question: Bumrah took 3 for 52, but the other three pacers managed just two wickets between them — Akash Deep one, Kamboj one and Prasidh none — as Henry Nicholls (113 not out) and Glenn Phillips (94 not out) added an unbroken 173 for the sixth wicket.
Assistant coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the selection after play. “There is nothing wrong with Siraj. We thought this was the best XI when we picked the side. I don’t think dropping Siraj was a wrong decision,” he said, adding the management had picked its strongest combination for the conditions. Whether that satisfies the critics is another matter — the exclusion is likely to remain a talking point for the rest of the series, with the second Test starting in Christchurch on November 27.
Related: Nicholls’ Unbeaten 113 and Phillips’ 94 Rescue New Zealand to 243/5 at Stumps on Day 1 in Wellington
